3 Months of AI Visibility Index Data: Here's What We've Learned About AI Search
Showcasing Who’s Winning AI Search
November 4, 2025
The automotive industry is built on bold moves, fierce competition, and data-driven outcomes. Jaguar’s rebrand was one of the most talked-about campaigns of the year—polarizing designs, inconsistent messaging, and endless debates. But when we strip away the opinions and noise, the data tells a very different story.
Spoiler alert: Flashy campaigns don’t equal sustained success.
The Loser: Jaguar’s Rebrand—A Flash in the Pan
Source: Semrush
Jaguar’s traffic tells a sobering story. Despite the bold rebrand and short-term spike on November 20 (76.8k visits), the buzz disappeared within days.
Just for reference, while Jaguar’s rebrand generated a fleeting spike of 76.8K visits, Tesla dominated with 1.4M visits.
Just for reference, while Jaguar’s rebrand generated a fleeting spike of 76.8K visits, Tesla dominated with 1.4M visits.
Source: Semrush
What Went Wrong?
- Traffic dropped back to baseline by November 24. The rebrand screamed for attention, but there was no follow-through to keep audiences engaged.
- Over-reliance on direct and organic search traffic. Jaguar’s sources were heavily skewed—41.42% from organic, 36.47% from direct. Paid, social, and email channels were nearly invisible.
- Missed opportunities across platforms. For example, brands like Hyundai, Kia, and Tesla leverage multi-channel strategies, while Jaguar not.
Source: Semrush
The Harsh Truth: Jaguar didn’t have enough traffic to lose in the first place. A spike without strategy isn’t a win—it’s a warning.
The Winners: Who’s Capturing Audience Attention?
As Jaguar’s rebrand struggled, the broader data paints a picture of the industry’s evolving dynamics. Here’s how the competition is faring:
- Tesla: Maintains dominance with 43.3M monthly visits through a tech-forward, multi-channel approach.
- Hyundai (+28.6%) and Kia (+15.3%): Emerge as the fastest-growing brands, driven by their focus on value and modern innovation, catering to younger, price-conscious buyers
- Porsche (+26.4%): Proved that luxury brands can innovate to reach new, younger audiences.
- BYD (+111.4%): Showcased the impact of an integrated, regional-first strategy.
Multichannel Strategies: The Key to Sustained Success
Analyzing traffic channels among top brands like Tesla, Kia, Hyundai, and Porsche highlights the critical importance of a multichannel approach.
Source: Semrush
- Multichannel Engagement drives higher, sustained traffic compared to reliance on one or two sources.
- Innovative Platforms like Instagram Reels and TikTok are key growth drivers for brands like Hyundai and Kia.
- Brands without diverse channel usage risk short-lived spikes, as Jaguar’s data illustrates.
For Jaguar, this is a critical takeaway: a lack of multichannel engagement severely limits long-term potential. A robust, diversified strategy is no longer optional; it’s essential for competing in the automotive space.
The Long Game: Lessons from Jaguar’s Missed Opportunity
- Awareness Without Engagement is Useless. Jaguar succeeded in creating noise, but buzz alone doesn’t build loyalty. Without deeper audience engagement, the spike was destined to fade.
- Value-Driven Strategies Win. Hyundai and Kia are proof that modern audiences prioritize value. Jaguar’s luxury pitch needs to evolve beyond aesthetics to meet real customer needs.
- Consistency is Non-Negotiable. VW and Mercedes are thriving because they deliver consistency in message, experience, and product. Jaguar’s inconsistent rebrand messaging only created confusion.
- Disruption is a Starting Point, Not the Goal. Tesla continues to dominate not because of one big moment, but because their entire machine is built for the long haul. Jaguar must learn to play this game.
Final Thoughts: Can Jaguar Turn Things Around?
Jaguar’s rebrand sparked conversation but fell short of creating impact where it matters—on the road to loyalty. Without a robust multi-channel strategy and value-driven messaging, this campaign risks becoming a cautionary tale for marketers.
The challenge for Jaguar:
The challenge for Jaguar:
- Shift from noise to meaningful connection.
- Diversify channels to engage audiences more effectively.
- Deliver consistent, value-focused messaging.
The automotive industry is evolving, and the winners will be those who connect meaningfully with their audiences—not just for a day, but for the long haul. Jaguar’s next steps will determine whether this rebrand marks the beginning of a comeback or the end of the road.
Unlocking Long-Term Success with Semrush’s Tools
Jaguar’s missed opportunity highlights the importance of leveraging data and insights to power campaigns. Here’s how Semrush can turn things around:
- Audience Insights: Using Semrush’s Traffic Analytics and Market Explorer, Jaguar could have uncovered untapped audience segments and fine-tuned their campaign to resonate with them.
- Channel Diversification: With Semrush’s Social Media Toolkit and Advertising Research, Jaguar could have designed a multi-channel strategy to increase visibility and engagement across platforms.
- Competitor Benchmarking: By benchmarking against leaders like Tesla or Kia, Jaguar could have adapted winning strategies to ensure long-term impact.
- SEO Optimization: Jaguar’s reliance on organic traffic underscores the need for enhanced keyword targeting and content alignment—an area where Semrush’s Keyword Magic Tool excels.
